The Muddy Place

Author’s note: I don’t condone the use of psychedelics for recreational purposes. I do recognize that there are psychedelics that can be used with positive outcomes for some psychiatric disorders. I am not a psychiatrist. You need to consult the proper medical person about using psychedelics. They should understand the proper use, and the protocols for their use.

In September I attended the Oxford trauma conference. It got me thinking about a question I’ve had for a while.

I want to talk about depression, trauma, and suicide. There are components of trauma in depression, and sometimes a person with depression considers suicide, and this is where it gets tricky. I’ll attempt to explain this dynamic.

When a person is depressed, their brain isn’t functioning correctly, and this is why finding the right drug is useful. The right drug will allow the brain to bypass the depression and cause things to work correctly. All of a sudden, when the pills kick in, neurons do what neurons should do. A person dealing with depression needs a pill to make it happen correctly. You can function again! I’m giving you the quick and simple explanation here. So, swallow the pill, and get out of bed to greet the day. This is when the cocktail you need to swallow works. You might need to adjust the cocktail periodically to keep things headed in the right direction. For most people, drugs and talk therapy are a good combination.  

What do you do when the drugs don’t work? Some depression is treatment resistant. Some depression is caused by the environment the person lives in. If the depression is caused by environment, getting free of that place is a good beginning. It is possible that the body has learned to be depressed; a good psychiatrist can help you use drugs in a limited way to help break the cycle. You must leave the toxic environment and find a good therapist who you can work with on overcoming the conditioning of the environment.

With treatment-resistant depression, no matter what the psychiatrist tries, no matter how fancy the cocktail of drugs is, the person struggles with the daily activities of life. They function on a limited basis. Some days are good, and others aren’t. This is where trauma and hopelessness come into a person’s life. The world has begun to turn the shade of a muddy yellow-brown, and slowly that is how the world is seen: no rose-colored glasses for these folks. It is an ugly color mix. This is where danger lies. You are too depressed to really think, and you don’t have the energy to think everything through. The person is trapped in the sludge of life—think of it as really slow-acting quicksand.

At some point in time the mind begins to ask the question that leads down a path that many see as forbidden: suicide. This is where the real trauma seeps into a person’s life. How can I think this? The shock and horror that I could consider ending my life can breed trauma within the soul. How could this thought be present in me? The muddy place thickens, and if you voice these concerns, friends panic, therapists jump to make a suicide contract, which doesn’t really work for those serious about ending it, and the person having the thought might shut down due to fear and social stigma. This only deepens the traumatic process going on inside.

As a therapist I am legally bound to keep a person safe, and that means prevent harm to self or others. As a therapist I want to have you talk about and explore your thoughts and fears. My job is to offer you a safe place to be heard.

In many ways, the person is facing an existential crisis of epic proportions: to stay and live, or to shut it all down. When a person thinks in this way, they’ve entered the war zone of thought. I don’t want a land mine to be triggered. You defuse the land mine by gently digging in around it, getting the fuse, and defusing it. I don’t want to blow it up. In this case, that is the wrong method of destruction.

I believe in hearing a person’s story and allowing them to come to terms with who they are and what they must face in life.

I listen, and you tell me your story. We find a way in to defuse the stuff inside. Together, we clear land mines. We hope for healthy defusing.

And now, there is something wonderful happening for people who are depressed and traumatized.

With all the buzz about MDMA, and the hope around its legalization for use in treatment of psychiatric disorders, it will be interesting to watch what can happen with its ethical use. I’m aware of its use for several DSM (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual) disorders.

Used correctly, and with medical supervision, there might be a pathway into the mind that could relieve the trauma of depression for many who suffer.

Don’t jump yet. MDMA has a medical protocol, and it might not be right for everyone. Don’t run out seeking this on the street. It is dosage specific and needs to be administered in a safe environment, and with a therapist and psychiatrist supervising the process. Used incorrectly and recreationally, ecstasy can damage a healthy brain. Used with clinical degression, it can serve as a healing agent.

This brings me to the question I’ve been mulling over: Could Jon have found some relief with MDMA? My answer at this point in time is that it might have enabled him to have some relief from the deep trauma that the depression had caused, but he would not have been a good candidate for this type of therapy due to a preexisting bipolar diagnosis. The protocol would have screened him out because bipolar and drugs aren’t a good idea.

Here I sit with hope for some, and hope that someday there will be hope for so many trapped in the muddy place.

Icebergs and Admirals, Part 2: Reshaping the Self

This is Part 2 in a series about trauma. Please read Part 1 here.

The admiral, in her boat, realizes that this gatekeeping for trauma must be shut down. Her text goes something like this: “Look, I get that there is trouble landside. If this destructive protection continues, I can no longer guarantee that the iceberg will remain stable. We need to shut this down, and do it in a controlled fashion. Let’s get the loyal soldiers of the mind sent out to retirement!”

What happens when the soldiers find out they will be let go is a joyous celebration. The soldiers didn’t want to have to serve as warriors. Who does? Trauma happens, and they get the job.

The process of releasing all trauma stored in the mind is a slow and careful one. With willing participants, it will be hard: it will also be worth the pain of it all. Going through the process is not a pleasant experience.

I mentioned in Part 1 that many people avoid the work of releasing the trauma because they fear that if they do so, they will fall apart, and dysfunction will ensue. Here’s a news bulletin: they are already in that dysfunctional zone! It is sensed by those who are avoidant to the work, and by those who are not able to see what is really going on underneath it all. Those in the second group feel that something is “off,” and while they don’t say anything due to a social contract, they do know that, deep down, things aren’t right.

This can set up clients to embark on a healing journey alone. Sometimes the client gets lucky and has one or two friends who get it. The friends agree to stand with the client in the journey.

Way back in “postland,” I wrote about being in the room with someone going through hard things. This is what good friends will do. I had two such people in my life, and while I knew there would be times when I had to sit with things all alone, I vaguely got where the boundaries and the limits were in that support. Trauma can mess that up for people, and relationships. I came to find out that I didn’t have the full understanding I needed with limits and friendship.

With all things in place, I went into the hard work of getting things repaired.

One by one, the land soldiers were called to the front of a battlement where, for the first time ever, their hard work was acknowledged, and they were excused with honor. Each time this process happened, the iceberg that was out at sea would shrink in its burden and grow in its beauty to become its full and true self.

The therapist allowed my words to stand, and honored them as I did. It was safe to claim my words. Sometimes the sessions left me in deep and dark places, and at other times the session was liberating. All of it worked to create the ability to come to terms with the awful, and to give thanks that I had done what I needed to do to heal the pain of the past.

The healing enabled me to understand that it wasn’t my fault. For some things that I had to let go of, I had been a child at the time. For other things, I had to come to terms with things that happened in my adult life. There were reframings and realizations that I had to revisit loyalties in relationships. All of it was hard and painful and sometimes lonely.

Each time I was able to release a soldier from the burden they had so loyally defended, I felt something float away from that iceberg, and the reason for the solider being there to defend things was no longer present. Over a period of months, things changed—until one day everyone had cleared out of the fortress that had stood for so long.

Now, the work of rebuilding could take place.

Rebuilding means that you can reach for the sun. We grieve the past and begin to celebrate a new future. What healing looks like is a slow discovery of a new life: a life where warriors are no longer needed, and they are sending text messages to admirals guarding icebergs. Now the admiral sends out messages to reject an attempt to ugly up the iceberg, and to get to work on addressing the present issue so that the iceberg will not become something unwanted and sent out to sea.

Healing means accepting the responsibility of facing the stuff head on. Where we once stuffed our trauma and sent it out to sea—to the iceberg—we are now able to assign ourselves to the greater task of dealing in the present. This is functional, and at first it will seem strange. Learning to know when to seek help is a new skill that we now come to face willingly.

It is strange because, for so many years, you did things that led you to feel yourself that you could cope—just like others. You went to school or work, the bills got paid, you did normal life stuff—and you did it stuffing everything away. You fooled yourself into believing it was all OK. It is the ultimate lie.

The ultimate truth is that humans are not made to live in a state of trauma for their entire lives. Trauma can cause illness, the inability to function at our highest capacity, and shattered relationships. Trauma will lead us to believe that all is really well when, in reality, all is not well at all: it is the ultimate lie masquerading as truth, and the ultimate truth is that it must all stop. And so, the delusion of safety shatters. The real sobbing is the signal that, at last, the soldiers of the mind can be released to go sip drinks on the warm beaches and relax from their labours.

Healing is all about doing the right things for the right reasons. Healing is about grieving what once was, and celebrating the light of discovering that there are better ways to do life.

Healing also means that the admiral guarding the iceberg is given permission to send what was once hidden beneath the surface back to land. The admiral now protects the iceberg in new ways. She tells the land folk that they are strong enough to handle what comes up in life.

As we strengthen muscles that have been dormant for some time, we learn what we missed out on. We celebrate the new life before us.

We have WOW moments, and we learn that we can move ahead. For the first time, the carnage of the life we lead is seen clearly. Healing is a series of incidents that lead us to new self-discovery. The work of healing from trauma is about being willing to say WOW as much as we need to. It is about finding the courage to do something real: heal ourselves.